Hello Dollface
Home » Makeup » Best Organic Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

Best Organic Mascara for Sensitive Eyes

Our top 10 picks for the best organic mascara for sensitive eyes that won't leave you with irritated, red eyes.
Best Organic Mascara For Sensitive Eyes- Close Up Brown Eyed Woman With Eye Makeup

*** All brands & products featured on hellodollface.com have been independently selected by our editors.  Some links in this article may be affiliate links, and things you buy through our links may earn us a commission.  You can view our full disclosure here.  Thanks for reading! ***

All my life I’ve been prone to dry eyes because just like my sensitive skin, I also have sensitive eyes.  I used to blame my red eyes on allergies or weather conditions so I’d always resort to using allergy-relief eye drops thinking that was all I could do. 

One day a friend asked me what mascara I was using and told me that my mascara could be drying my eyes out and making them red!   At the time, I’d been transitioning from using conventional makeup to using pretty much only clean, cruelty free makeup and natural skincare so I assumed the natural mascara I was using wasn’t going to irritate my sensitive eyes.

It really all depends on how the makeup is formulated. Even 100% natural and organic makeup can make my sensitive eyes and sensitive skin irritated, red, and puffy.  Mascara is applied very close to the eyes so even the slightest hint of an irritant will cause a reaction to sensitive eyes.

We scoured the internet in search of the best rated organic mascara for sensitive eyes.  All of the mascara included in our list are made with organic ingredients that will nourish and hydrate your lashes.  And as a reminder, everyone is different and even organic mascara can cause irritations for some people. Keep reading for our top 10 picks for the best organic mascara for sensitive eyes that promise to not leave you with irritated, red eyes.

Mineral Mascara by EVXO
  • STRENGTHENS & LENGTHENS – EVXO’s Organic Mascara is made with natural and organic ingredients to keep your lashes strong, healthy and looking longer than ever! Our Natural Mascara is the perfect replacement for your average harmful chemical drugstore mascara!
  • GENTLE AND NON-TOXIC – You won’t find any artificial colors, harmful preservatives, or fragrances in our Mascara! This is the best mascara for sensitive eyes!
  • SOFT, LONG, LUSH LASHES – Our Mineral Mascara Makeup adds volume and length while applying evenly and smoothly with no flakes, clumps or smudges. Apply one coat for a natural finish or add multiple coats for a dramatic look! You can easily maintain your natural beauty with this organic makeup.

Better’n Ur Lashes Organic Mascara
  • ♥ GROW HEALTHIER LASHES: Silky Smooth & Smudge Proof | Seriously Thick & Long Lashes | Grow Thicker, Longer Lashes | Stop Unnecessary Lash Fallout from Toxic Chemicals!
  • ♥ TEAR RESISTANT & HYPOALLERGENIC: If Most Eye Cosmetics Irritate your Eyes Ours Probably Won’t! Great for Contact Users & Eye Conditions like Blepharitis, Sensitive Eyes, Dry Eyes
  • ♥ LONG LASTING & BUILDABLE VOLUME: Longer, thicker lashes that look Natural OR Dramatic (use 2 coats for drama). Let dry completely between coats to thicken and lengthen even more. Use under top lashes and on top for best results.

Organic Wear Fake Out Mascara from Physicians Formula
  • Curls, volumes, conditions, and nourishes
  • 100% Natural origin
  • Hypoallergenic. Dermatologist Tested. Clinically Tested. Cruelty Free.

Aphrodite Natural Mascara by Papillon
  • Natural, Vegan Mascara: Give your eyes a healthy, organic boost with our high-performance, NON-GMO mascara. Formulated with added plant-based botanical extracts, our luxurious formula defines, lengthens and enhances lashes for beautiful eyes that pop!
  • Organic Chamomile Mascara: The Rosemary & Chamomile combination in every stroke of the mascara brush, along with Sunflower Oil, stimulates strong and healthy lash hair growth. Grapeseed Oil further nourishes lashes and keeps them healthy
  • Non-Clumping Mascara: Papillon mascara is smudge, flake, and clump-resistant. Our formula separates and defines your lashes for a long-lasting clean-lash look! The volumizing brush grabs the smallest lashes, giving each lash a vitamin boost

Organic Mascara by Endlessly Beautiful
  • 🌿 MAKES LASHES LOOK LONGER AND FULLER – Voluminous mascara that goes on smoothly without clumps, flakes, or smudges. This great lengthening mascara is the best mascara for thickening and lengthening eyelashes.
  • 🌿 ALL NATURAL MAKEUP MASCARA – This black mascara is non toxic and free of harmful chemicals. It is the best mascara for sensitive eyes and contact wearers, enriched with nourishing ingredients that promote eyelash growth. This vegan mascara is safe, gentle and moisturizing. It is gluten & paraben free and is 100% cruelty free makeup.
  • 🌿 STAYS ON ALL DAY – This long lasting volume mascara is water resistant and sweat proof. It the best mascara for length and volume that is easy to apply and easy to remove from your lashes at the end of the day.

RMS Beauty Volumizing Mascara, Black – Organic, Natural Plant Waxes Shape & Intensify Lash Fullness
  • RMS Beauty Mascara is available in two different formulas to add either definition or volume, and create beautiful, lush lashes.
  • Add life to your lashes by intensifying fullness and defining your lashes.
  • The Defining Mascara is both creamy and rich, and this unique formula separates and defines lashes naturally for an overall dramatic eye.

Emani Organic Soy Mascara – Midnight
  • Separates, curls and lengthens lashes
  • Smudge proof formula for all day wear
  • Contains natural ingredients that promote lash strength and health


Last update on 2024-06-17 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Verified by MonsterInsights